« Responsibility of the Educated | Main | Congratulations to the 2011 AVID graduates »
Friday
Jun102011

Is College Really a Waste of Time? 

By Tom Holman, Director, Morning Foundation

I just finished reading the article on CNN.com where a 19 year-old entrepreneur, Dale Stephens points out that for him, “College is a waste of time.”  Dale is one of the lucky recipients of a $100,000 grant given by PayPal founder Peter Thiel to 20 entrepreneurs under 20 years old to fund their projects, with the catch that they cannot be enrolled in college.

Mr. Thiel’s grants have made headlines and have caused a number of opinion columnists to question the value of attaining a college degree in this day and age.  The basic argument I’ve seen reiterated goes something like this:  College is expensive, so you’re better off just getting a job straight out of high school, not incurring any student loans, and starting to save for your retirement right away.

There is some validity to this argument, as colleges have gotten more expensive, and not all college graduates find high paying jobs.  But if you are considering skipping college and going straight into the workforce, I encourage you to think clearly about the ramifications of your decision.  In determining the value of a college degree, I suggest you research the costs and assess the value to you and not base your decision on the opinion of a columnist.

Regarding costs, there are several things to consider.  At the high end, many private colleges publish a total cost of attendance of over $50,000 per year.  But keep in mind, around $15,000 of this amount is for room and board.  If you are on your own, working or attending college, you have to pay for your room in board anyway, so let’s focus on tuition.  The College Board reports that while the published rates for private college tuition and fees are in the range of $35,000, nearly half of all full-time undergraduate students attend a four-year college with published charges of less than $9,000 per year in tuition and fees.  And most students do not pay the published rate.  On average, public four-year colleges charge $7,605 per year for in-state students, and the average charge for 2-year colleges is $2,713.  For lower income students, the costs are typically even less, and there are many options for financing the cost of college.  Federal Pell grants are available up to $5,550 per year, and many states provide additional grants of $1,500-$2,500 per year.

Now, let’s look at the value of a college degree or certificate.  We’ll consider the impact on getting a job as well as getting a job you actually enjoy.  A key consideration is that without a post-secondary degree or certificate your chances of getting a job are greatly reduced.  In today’s economy, getting a job is pretty tough, and it is a lot tougher for those without a post-secondary education.  In the U.S., our overall unemployment rate is 9.1%.  For all high school graduates without a post-secondary education, the rate is slightly higher, at 9.5%.  But for college graduates, unemployment is only 4.5% (US Dept. of Labor).  When you look closer at the rates for young people, the situation is really tough right now.  Unemployment for ages 18-25 with only a high school diploma is currently over 50%, but the jobless rate for those under 25 with a college degree is only 8%.

I believe it is hard to argue that skipping college so you can start working is a viable financial alternative when over half of the young people out of high school are unemployed. 

And what about the kind of job you can get with more education?

The US Census Bureau (and many others) show that the average pay for a job with a college degree earns almost twice the average for those with a high school diploma ($58,600 vs. $31,300). Over a lifetime of work, higher education will yield $800,000 more in wages.  And pay is not the entire story.  The jobs available to those with a post-secondary education are typically more interesting, there is more mobility between jobs, and there are more advancement opportunities within companies.  In other words, a college degree or certificate will greatly enhance your ability to get a job you enjoy.  In addition to actually liking your work and getting paid more for it, the Institute for Higher Education Policy points out a number of additional benefits including more leisure time, more opportunities for civic engagement, better health, less reliance on government services, and having children that are far more likely to be successful in school.

Of course, there will always be exceptions, such as a handful of highly successful entrepreneurs like Bill Gates and Michael Dell who were very successful without completing college, but the fact of the matter is that 97% of CEOs in America have a college degree (Spencer Stuart, 2004 CEO Study).  And by the way, Michael Dell is big believer in higher education, as he has invested millions through his own foundation on programs like AVID and college scholarships.

Speaking of AVID, you might be interested in the article I wrote a couple of years ago, noting the value AVID brings to college preparation.

As you think about whether college is a waste of your time or not, I would encourage you to consider what your life will be like on each side of the fence, the side with and without a post-secondary education.  Without a post-secondary education, do you believe that you will have success in finding a job you enjoy in this economy that pays you what you are capable of earning?  Some will, by no doubt, but I think the odds are against it.

 

For me, I will continue to encourage young people to pursue the highest level of education they can to maximize their personal potential not only for their own benefit, but also for the benefit of society. 

Tom Holman is the director of the Morning Foundation, a private foundation dedicated to helping address issues around children’s health, education, and social service.  Tom is currently focusing efforts on helping more underserved students access college and persist to graduation. 

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (7)

Greetings! I am an AVID Elective Teacher and push for my AVID student to focus on the future.

I just heard on NPR an interviewee talking about the value of going to college. The basic premise what the college might not be the best option for some. It is expensive. However, it went deeper.

They pointed out that some colleges are simply credentialing students with a degree after four years. They aren't teaching students to be successful. They aren't building a passion in students that is going to lead to an enjoyable career.

In my mind, if the only reason you are going to college is to get a degree, then you are doing it wrong. You must have a reason, like everything else in life, for going to college. Simply going because it is the thing to do is a mistake.

I can't in good conscience promote spending lots of money just because it is what you are supposed to do.

You should go to college if you have a passion for something and it will make a difference in your career goals. If you don't have that passion, you should go to college only if you can find a college that is going challenge you and get you to where you have a deeper sense of what you want to do.

You should not graduated from college, after spending all that money, and not know where you career is headed.

I teach middle schooler AVID students and I do my best to expose them to careers through guest speakers, research, and experience.

June 11, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterMr. K

In response to the previous comment, college is about finding that passion. College IS "the thing to do" and to tell students that they shouldn't pursue higher education unless they have a passion for a career is like telling a six-year-old not to go to kindergarten unless he or she has a passion for the alphabet. And it's about more than a career. College is about growing as a thinker, learning to contribute to our society, and discover who we really are as a person. Undergraduate school affords us an opportunity to safely explore our world and what it has to offer. Sometimes the student with the least direction leaving high school needs college the most. It is a shame when these students are convinced by their parents and other adults whom they trust not to "waste time and money going to a four-year" and instead opt for a two year where they can "get their GE out of the way". The problem with this advice is that community colleges can't provide the student with a breadth of scholastic experiences wherein he or she can find what interests them the most. These students don't get hooked into college in the same way that students who attend a four-year do. They often find college boring and, since they are still living at home and working their same high school job, tend to drop out because the community college hasn't helped them find their passion.

June 13, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterDiane Boyd

Diane and Mr. K,

We appreciate these insights. You are focused on the right aspects of college. Please look for our blog soon on the comments of Mike Rose, a professor from UCLA, who shares your sentiments.

And thanks to Tom Holman for stimulating the discussion.

June 14, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterRob Gira

Diane,

Thank you for your response to my comment. I think we are both "preaching to the choir."

My objection is that I know there are students in college just because they need a college degree. I find this both in former students I have reconnected with on Facebook and in the graduate level teacher technology course I teach. In the latter, I see, on a weekly basis, learners sitting in class taking up space. They have no desire to be in class (which makes me question why they want to be a teacher). In the former, there are students finishing school with no idea what they want to do. That, to me, is a failure of the higher education system.

I do believe that the objective of middle schools is to get students successfully prepared for high school while instilling the AVID hope for the future. I also believe that the role of high school is to prepare students for higher ed while instilling the AVID hope for the future.

After that, students should go on to college and colleges should do everything they can to get students onto a successful, passion-filled career and life.

Lastly, and then I'll be done, I whole heartedly endorse a 4 year college. More specifically, I recommend a small 4 year college. The lessons I learned outside of the classrooms were just as valuable, if not more so, than any learning inside the classroom. You don't get that experience living at home or in an apartment and attending a 2 year school where students come to class and go home.

Great dialogue. Thanks!!

June 14, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterMr. K

Mr. K, we are lucky to have you as an AVID elective teacher. Thanks for helping middle schoolers "see the light." Have a great summer.

June 15, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterRob Gira

@Mr. Gira, Thank you for the compliment. I do appreciate it and I do feel lucky to have given the opportunity to teach the AVID Elective. I am already having a great summer. Spent this afternoon with my personal kids at a waterpark. Can't be better!!!

June 15, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterMr. K

I think that the person who originally stated that, "college is a waste of time", had the right opportunities to succeed without college. Even though he is successful without college the same isn't true for everyone. A lot of lower income students did not get the same teachings this guy has gotten. Would they know the business or networking aspect? I think this is a big thing to consider when debating on if college is worth it or not. College can open up doors for low income students that would not normally have otherwise.

August 4, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterBarbara L.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>